Nostalgia 1997: The Eight Doctors


Image Credit: James Ashworth

Image Description: A copy of The Eight Doctors

By James Ashworth

Contains some 20 year old spoilers…

With the BBC having taken back the rights for Doctor Who novels from Virgin, and after the failure of relaunching the series, they launched a new series of books, the Eighth Doctor Adventures, in order to continue The Doctor’s travels. So where else to start reviewing than at the beginning of this series, which was, as you may have guessed, The Eight Doctors by Terrance Dicks.

Beginning shortly after the events of the movie, the Eighth Doctor manages a whole page before the Master springs a trap on him. From having a dodgy memory in the TV movie, the Doctor now goes the whole hog and gains severe amnesia, forgetting everything about his and his previous incarnations’ lives. With the aid of a familiar voice, he manages to land the TARDIS somewhere familiar. And where else would a new Doctor start than at the very beginning, in the yard of one I.M Foreman, which for some reason still hasn’t been built on despite being left absent for 34 years. And what else does a new Doctor need? A companion! After a quick fight and a trip to the police station, the Doctor takes his new companion, Samantha Jones, aboard, and begins travelling again. Or not. Stumbling into the TARDIS, he disappears just as Sam is surrounded by a gang intent on silencing her…

The Doctor now starts on his journey to recover his memories, taking in some of the greatest hits of his previous 7 lives. Taking in serials such as 100,000BC, The War Games, The Sea Devils and The 5 Doctors, the Doctor ends up meeting his other selves, filling in his memories by linking minds with them, sadly without shouting ‘contact’. There are 2 distinct types of interaction with previous incarnations here. The stories involving the first 2 Doctors end up with the Doctor directly influencing the events of that story, which feel like a bit of an insult to Doctors 1 and 2. For example, it changes The War Games so that the 2nd Doctor gets the idea of contacting the Time Lords from the 8th Doctor. Now admittedly, The Doctor as a whole still came up with the idea, but surely the 2nd Doctor is capable of thinking for himself, and it somewhat taints the idea that contacting the Time Lords was the Doctor’s last resort, giving his own freedom up in return for the inhabitants of the games being transported home.

The other set of interactions are much better, featuring the 8th Doctor meeting himself offscreen. He goes full Buffy on some Vampires after State of Decay, he finds the 7th Doctor captured on Metebelis III, and thwarts the Master along with the 3rd Doctor after the events of The Sea Devils. These, as well as being a nostalgia fest, also allow some other fun moments. You wanted the backstory of the Raston Warrior Robot? You got it! You want the Master in Tartan? Have that too! You want Adric? Well too bad, he sleeps through his segment.

Meanwhile, in the background, a good old bit of Time Lord political shenanigans plays out. While it may not be The Deadly Assassin, it is still suitably entertaining and interesting. It sees the return of some familiar faces, with those from the Five Doctors featuring prominently. However, given that Terrance Dicks wrote that as well, it is not all that surprising. It also gives the opportunity to tie up some loose ends and plot holes from other linked stories, be they the Master’s change into a worm in the Movie, or some threads from The Trial of a Time Lord (Only some though). It also throws up an interesting point, when one of the Time Lords makes a sexist remark about President Flavia. Admittedly, whether the novels exist in the main continuity of Who seems to be up to the reader, but it is interesting given recent revelations about regeneration, with characters such as the Corsair in The Doctor’s Wife, The Master in Dark Water and the General in Hell Bent showing that regenerations can cause a change in gender. Surely such behaviour would not exist in a society where such changes are but a regeneration away, or is this unwitting commentary on some of the hypocrisy of the Time Lords? You decide.

And back to the business of getting a companion. Eventually finding the time to go and save Sam, vanquish the thugs and generally save the day, the original ‘Smith and Jones’ begin their adventures together. Whereas a conventional companion, especially modern ones, normally get much more time in their first story, Sam barely features, this being much more the story of the Doctors. If you want to see Sam in action, you are going to have to read more of the books in the series.

Overall, if you are looking for a calm way to satisfy your Doctor Who cravings, look no further. There are no complex causal loops or paradoxes to get your head round, no complex story to get lost in, while still being perfectly entertaining. Admittedly, this may contribute to some of the low points, like most of the incarnations shown needing saving by the 8th, or the aforementioned meddling in the stories of other Doctors. While it may not hit the heights of what Doctor Who fiction can achieve, it easily misses the lows, so enjoy as Terrance Dicks weaves together a fun tale, with a healthy amount of nostalgia, action and intrigue thrown in for good measure, that serves as a perfect introduction to this series of books.

The rest of Tides 39 can be found online here

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s